5.04.2012

Cosby Funhouse!



__________________________________________________+++
And now, in celebration of Bill Cosby performing in Peoria this Saturday I now present to you the Cosby funhouse!












qm.gif











http://billcosbypokemon.ytmnd.com/ (let it loop ad infinitum)



















5.01.2012

My Comedy Problem: Bill Cosby






This Saturday (May 5) my wife and I are going to see Bill Cosby perform live at the Peoria Civic Center Theater.  I am incredibly excited about this.  Not only is he a living legend but he has had a significant influence on what I think is funny.  I think The Cosby Show is one of the definitive examples of a family sitcom--it is about a strong husband and wife who truly love each other and their kids but who also go through a whole slew of problems.  The show has produced some of the funniest moments in TV history and some of the funniest moments in my own life (I'm thinking especially of "The Regular People" segment as well as the "Theo Gets an Earring" segment).  As a kid, I only knew about him from The Cosby Show but as an adult I have really come to appreciate him more as a stand-up comedian. I have listened to a lot of stand-up in the last few years and have come to see it as a really pure and daring art form.  It is just one person standing up in front of a group of people, telling them stories, trying to connect with them on a personal level, trying to reveal some kind of truth we can all relate to, and, of course, trying to make them laugh.


Leading up to the concert this Saturday I have been listening to a lot of Cosby’s stand-up.  While most of his material consists of what would be considered middle of the road familial humor (either stories of his childhood years or his experiences of being a father and a husband) he always uses an unsentimental approach and often incorporates off-the-wall and absurd humor into his sketches.  Even though I have been listening to records that are thirty and forty years old, his material still seems fresh and it seems like he has new things to say despite the fact that his subjects are well-trodden territory.  Essentially, what I am saying is that Cosby is amazing.

This does not mean, however, that I have no reservations about the show I am going to see.  I actually have some fears about whether it will be worth our money (actually, my mother-in law’s money—it was a gift to my wife for her birthday [thanks Bev!].  I will explain my fears by posting an email I sent to comedian Marc Maron who hosts the WTF Podcast, a bi-weekly free podcast consisting of Marc interviewing the best comedic minds around today.




Dear Marc,

          I am writing to you because I have a comedy problem and I think (actually I know) you will understand it.  In fact, the problem has arisen because of something I learned on your show about what comedy should be.  Let me explain.

          This Saturday, May 5 I am going to see Bill Cosby live in concert in Peoria, Illinois (my hometown) at the Peoria Civic Center Theater.  I am very excited about this as it is the first time I will ever actually get to see live stand-up comedy and I will be seeing a living legend--one of my favorite comics who has made me laugh since I was a kid.  At the same time, I am really nervous that I will be disappointed in the show; that it will all be a BIG letdown.

          My worries all started when I went to buy the tickets at the box office of the Civic Center (I wanted to avoid the Ticket Master fees).  When I went up to the booth and told the ticket clerk which show I wanted to see I asked him if he had ever seen Cosby before.  He said, “Oh yeah, a few times before.  He’s just great.”  I then asked him if he knew what material Cosby usually does.  The clerk said “Oh you know, he does his usual stuff. (brief pause) What I really like about him though is that he does a good clean show—nothing raunchy.  It’s something the whole family can go to.”

          When I heard this my heart sank—even though I did not let on to the clerk.  You see, in recent years I have heard that Cosby’s routine has gotten a little rawer, that he has kind of become this somewhat cynical old man character who “just tells it like it is” and not just a lowest common denominator comedian trying to appease the masses.  Now listen, I know who Cosby is.  I know he has always been a mass appeal comedian, always talking about childhood, parenthood, male/female tensions, and any other subjects that relate to a general audience.  But in the past few weeks I have been listening back to a lot of his old stand-up and despite the middle of the road material I don’t think Cosby ever really plays it safe.  In what I have heard so far he has talked about his daughter’s growing breasts and getting their periods, the sticky messy blankets from his son’s wet dreams, sneakily visiting a Japanese masseuse without telling his wife, trying to find the drug Spanish Fly, the unsavory aspects of a woman birthing a baby, and calling his kids “brain damaged.”  Sure I think he is trying to appeal to the masses, but in a bold way.






          My worry is not that Cosby won’t use swear words—that is, my concern isn’t about a lack of vulgarity.  Instead I fear he will not tell us the truth.  A number of times on the podcast I have heard you talk about how no matter what a comedian’s schtick is, the most important thing is whether or not he or she is telling the truth, whether or not they have the boldness to stand up in front of people and reveal something uncomfortable and still funny—about themselves, about the audience, or about the world we live in.  As I was walking away from buying the tickets it hit me that I was going to see Cosby play in Peoria—the most mediocre place in America (at least as far as stereotypes go).  Cosby is a master at his craft and my fear is that he won’t really challenge us as an audience; that he will know this is Peoria and just play it safe, appealing to the lowest common denominator, throwing out the easiest things that can make an audience laugh.

          During your interview with Chris Rock (ep. 224), he was reflecting on his favorite comedians and he compared Richard Pryor (who originated from Peoria) to Willie Mays because he was the flashiest player and the most fun to watch.  Then he compared Cosby to Hank Aaron, because even though he was not flashy everyone knew he was the greatest ever.  I thought that was a wonderful comparison and I think what I fear is that the show on Saturday will not be a baseball game but a homerun derby where Hank Aaron takes a few pitches, knocks them out of the park, waves to the audience, and then signs a few autographs.  I don’t really care if Cosby can show up to a publicity fundraising event to please the fans.  I want to know if he can still get in the game and compete and maybe even steal a few bases.

          This is my fear and I am sure you understand where I am coming from.  I do not expect a response from you, but as fan of your comedy and your podcast I thought you would be interested to hear my perspective.

          I still have high hopes that it will be a great show!

          Best Regards,

                   Chris Marchand
                   May 2012
_____________________________________________________________________+++
And here is Marc's jolting and much appreciated response:


Dude, it's Cosby. Relax and be happy you will have seen him before he died. He was never lowest common denominator. I don't know what you are talking about. His truths were family truths and human truths. He will never be vulgar or use language. He's fucking Cosby. 

What's the matter with you? Go watch the old man talk and be forgiving. He's still up there doing it. If you want Vintage Cosby watch 'Himself'. It's not going to get better than that. 

maron


_____________________________________________________________________+++
Later this week stay tuned for Cosby Funhouse!


And below, please enjoy a segment from Cosby's landmark comedy album Himself:







 

4.27.2012

Unanswerable Questions #2: Keith Green

Unanswerable Questions--an ongoing segment here at PostConsumer Reports where I ask questions to people of interest who will most likely never answer them, simply because I do not know them and probably never will. Still, the questions come and I have got to ask them somewhere. I have so many questions. So so many...


To my surprise, the last time I did this segment my questions actually got answered.  I posted a link to my blog onto Fernando Ortega's blog and he was gracious enough to go to that link and give some serious answers to my questions.


I do not foresee the same thing happening this time, because my questions are being posed to Keith Green, who has been dead for nearly 30 years now (July 29, 1982).  My last post was specifically about Green and I have been listening to his music a lot in the past couple of weeks.  A number of questions have popped into my mind during that time--questions that will basically have to go unanswered.  What I am really curious about, that is, what I really want to know is what Green would be doing now with his ministry and music and if his views would have changed at all in the last 30 years.


So here is what I would ask him in 2012:


1. Let's get this out of the way first: Why is the song "My Eyes Are Dry" from the album No Compromise so short?  Why does it trail off just as the second chorus begins to kick in? Is there a longer version of the song that exists?


2. Out of all your songs which do you hope will endure in the Church?  Out of your singer-songwriter type songs which do you hope people will still be listening to in a hundred years and out of your worship songs which do you hope the Church will still be singing?


3. You are famous for giving your music away, as you saw it as a vehicle for communicating the Gospel.  Nowadays plenty of artists are giving their music away and added to that there's really nothing an artist can do to stop people from illegally downloading their music.  In 2012 would you still see your music only as a vehicle for the Gospel and would you still be giving it away?  In an age when music has been commodified into easily transferable digital information (that is, people do not really have to work to get it anymore) what does it mean to "give away" music?  On top of that, do you think it is acceptable for a Christian artist to charge for their work, especially if they see themselves less as ministers of the Gospel and more as artists trying to earn a living? Also, if your ministry were still around do you think it would be more focused on the music, more on the preaching, or an even mixture of the two? (BTW-I know Melody Green, Keith's wife, still has a vital ministry going with Last Days Ministries, but this is not what I am asking)


4. Do you think Christian artists can have different callings?  For example, does God call some artists to be evangelistic in their focus, others to comfort and/or challenge the Church, and others to create art that simply glorifies God by telling a good story or by being beautiful?


5. The message of your song "Jesus Commands Us to Go" is simply that as Christians we are all called to go out into the world and spread the good news of Jesus, and indeed you spent the last part of your life encouraging people to "go" somewhere other than America.  In 21st century America we basically live in a post-Christian society, or at least this is becoming the prevalent paradigm in our culture; I know this to be the case amongst most of the 20-40 year-olds I know.  Currently I am planting a church in my home town of Peoria, Illinois and even though it is a highly churched city from an outward viewpoint there are so many people here who have rejected the Church, the Christian faith, and Christ himself.  Have your thoughts on where Christians should "go" in terms of mission changed at all since you wrote that song?


6. Before you died you were working on some songs that would be part of a rock opera or concept album of sorts based on different Biblical parables and stories.  You completed "The Prodigal Son Suite" and "On the Road to Jericho" (about the Good Samaritan) but I am curious what other parables and stories you wanted to include in that work.


7. When was the recording of "The Prodigal Son Suite" and what was that recording session like?  Was all the orchestration recorded after your death or before?  Did you record the piano for it in one continuous take or did you piece together a bunch of takes?  When were all those posthumously released songs recorded?  Was your recording process to record a ton of songs for a record and then a bunch of songs did not get on it, which is why so many songs of yours have been released since you died?  And finally, did you compose the orchestration for your songs or was someone else in charge of that?  As an example I am thinking of a song like "The Victor" which has some complex orchestration in it, not just the strings but also the guitar.  Was the composition of all those parts up to you or was it a collaborative effort?


8. Every time I have heard you speak and in a number of your songs you use a lot of humor, sometimes bitingly satirical and sometimes rather zany and off-the-wall.  Even in some of your most serious or sad songs you will throw in something comical.  What role do you think humor can play in helping people to see truth and who has made you laugh in your life?  What were some of your favorite movies, tv shows, and comedians?

4.12.2012

"Easter (Song") Reflection: Why Celebrating Easter Eventually Always Makes Me Think of Keith Green


I have a confession to make. Sometime during high school (probably in 1997 or 1998) I stole the sheet music book for Keith Green’s The Ministry Years Vol. 1 out of my church’s music room. For some reason I had wandered back behind the stage after the worship service where the amps and all the extra microphone stands were kept when I noticed a shelf of sheet music and guitar chord books. Most of the shelf was taken up with the thick binders that contained all of my church’s repertoire in alphabetical order along with a bunch of Maranatha, Integrity, and Vineyard worship books which did not really interest me. And then I saw the Keith Green book. It was like someone had placed it there just for me, as if they knew I had been obsessed with his music for months now and had been dying to learn some of his songs on piano, even though I knew very well the skill level required to play them was beyond my abilities. There was one song in particular I wanted to learn more than any other, “Easter Song,” and it just so happened that is was contained within this volume. The signs could not have been any clearer. I was supposed to take the book. I told myself that I would keep it just until I learned how to play “Easter Song” and then I would give it back. This was meant to be, this was for God’s greater glory--there was simply no other way to see it.
Well, I kept my word. Since I never learned to play the whole song (I only managed to get through the opening riff) I still have the book and it is sitting on top of my piano right now next to a Delirious and a Rich Mullins songbook (both of which I paid for!). I have always wondered if the book actually belonged to the church--that is, if it was paid for with church money for church purposes--or if it belonged to someone’s private collection and they had brought it in and left it at church for any number of reasons. I have always wondered if it has been missed, if it was a cherished possession or just one book among many.

My goals for learning the song were many. For starters I simply wanted to play it for my own enjoyment and worship to God because it was and still is my favorite Keith Green song even though he did not even write it (more on that in a bit). But on top of that I had fantasies of playing it in front of my church on Easter morning whereby a mass of people chose to follow Christ simply because the song was performed (helped a little bit, of course, by my expert playing and singing). The cheesy Passion plays my church put on out of evangelistic motivations held nothing to the power of this song. As soon as the people heard me belt out those high C’s and even that last A above a high C just like Keith did (in most likely a screamed falsetto), they would know Jesus was Lord, that he had risen from the dead, and would come rushing to the stage to put their faith in him.

I still dream of that happening, although I would be perfectly happy hitting an A an octave below that high high A (A5 or A880, if you are curious). There was always a kid in youth group who could really play Keith Green songs on piano, Nathan Hoffman, and I was always really jealous of him. I do not think I ever heard him play “Easter Song” though, which was fine by me; I wanted that to be my jurisdiction (his speciality was playing the masterful “Prodigal Son Suite”) [By the way, Nathan currently makes some amazing videos and I am reminded that we should hang out more often].

I am disappointed I never learned to play the whole song and especially that I never performed it, but the song is still very much a part of me. It is one of the most powerful songs I have ever heard musically speaking, which is appropriate since on a macro scale it is about the most important historical event of all time (i.e., “The Christ Event” culminating in his death, resurrection, and ascension) and on a micro scale the song is about the most important event that can occur in an individual’s life (i.e., making Christ one’s Lord and choosing to follow him). A few weeks ago while waiting in a parking lot to play tennis with a friend I listened to the song no less than four times and on Easter Sunday itself I got to listen to it on vinyl at my in-law's house cranked all the way up! (thanks Rich!) To me, the song typifies the joy of receiving salvation, the joy of knowing that he is risen, that despite all my weaknesses he still reigns, and also the joy experienced in seeing others come to know him. As an Anglican, I have come to appreciate the glorious “alleluias” in the refrain after enduring the wilderness of an alleluia-less Lent, as well as the reference to "bells ringing," which is something we Anglicans like to do a lot of on Easter.



As a child the ultimate Easter song for me was Don Francisco’s “He’s Alive.” I loved the slow build of that song, with the many repetitive troubadour-styled minor-keyed verses culminating in the climactic proclamation that “He’s alive! He’s alive! He’s alive and I’m forgiven. Heaven’s gates are opened wide...” Both “Easter Song” and “He’s Alive” are trying to say and accomplish the same things, with the former being an incredibly condensed version of the latter from a storytelling perspective. For some reason I did not really grow up listening to Keith Green, which is why it was such a revelation to me when I really heard it for the first time in high school.

There was this place I and a bunch of my friends went to called The Cabin near the small town of Tremont where every month they had music concerts put on by local Christian bands. I have had a few experiences in my life where I really felt like I connected with someone right away at a deep level and that happened one night after a show at The Cabin. I had just met a guy who was a few years older than me and who went to the same high school I did named Adam Shrepfer. He was a whirlwind of passion and I could see that his faith in God ran deep. I cannot remember anything about our conversation except that we talked a lot about God and probably music, and then at the end he told me that I had to, absolutely must listen to Keith Green’s music. I said OK and then he helped to ensure that I actually would by going to his car and getting a dubbed tape of Keith Green music.

I listened to the tape endlessly in the ensuing weeks, eventually buying both Vol. 1 and 2 of The Ministry Years (first on cassette and then CD), reading his wife Melody’s post-humous biography No Compromise, and then finding out everything I could about Green and all the people who had influenced him. I am still grateful to Adam Shrepfer for the wonderful gift he gave me, even though I have not seen him in years (in fact, he is also a key influence in me becoming Anglican as well, but that is another story). When I learned that Green liked to give away his albums to everyone who wanted one since to him they were a vehicle for the Gospel, it helped me to have little hesitation months later when it came to stealing the music book from my church. “Keith would have wanted me to have this book” I told myself.



Now realize, basically the whole time I have loved this song I knew Keith Green did not even write it. He did add the second verse of the song in his recorded version, but the songwriting credit goes to Anne Herring and her band 2nd Chapter of Acts. I did not get around to hearing the original version until few years ago I when I purchased a greatest hits of sorts from the band. I think both versions of the song are perfect, but Green’s is definitely the superior, despite some wicked sweet keyboards in 2nd Chapter’s version. Green is so passionate, so heartfelt, and the recording contains the raw exhilaration of someone young in their faith. It gives me chills to this day and helps me to recall the joy of my salvation.

We are now in the Easter Season (April 8-May 27, culminating in the Day of Pentecost) and despite all the wonderful resurrection and salvation themed hymns I have learned since my teenage years, for me this one song typifies the season more than any other. It is the exuberant joy of finding and being found in salvation, of knowing that death has been conquered, that we have been set free, and our savior reigns victorious.

Have a joyous Easter season!+++Postconsumer Reports


Enjoy the videos below:




2.13.2012

Interview Exclusive!: Musician Patrick Jenkins


Patrick Jenkins is a singer/songwriter from Central Illinois and is quickly becoming a good friend of mine. We initially met through the pastor of my church and have since bonded over our love of music and our experience with the world of Contemporary Christian Music. At one time Patrick was a songwriter, lead singer, and keyboardist for the band Two Cent Offering. Now he has taken on a role as a worship leader at St. Marks Lutheran Church in Washington, Illinois and is also a husband and a father. Back in December of last year Patrick helped my church out when we put on a carol sing at a local coffee shop. He had just released his EP back in November and graciously gave me a copy of it when I asked him for one (I still owe him 5 bucks by the way). Since then, I have really enjoyed listening to Appeal To Heaven
, a collection of folk music that contains heartfelt songs of faith and encouragement and some stellar cover art (see picture below). I recently sat down with Patrick (he sitting comfortably at his home computer, me waiting expectantly in front of my own computer) and asked about the recording experience, what motivates his songwriting, and about being a worship leader.

+++ +++ +++

PostConsumer Reports: I know you are an avid listener of folk, rock, and gospel music and that has obviously influenced your songwriting. When you sit down to write a song do you ever consciously incorporate those influences or do they just unconsciously seep in? I think more than a certain style that is coming out it

Patrick Jenkins: I think more often than not, they just creep in. I don’t spend a ton of time writing a song unless there is something that is connecting with me in the combination of lyrics, melody, and chords and at this point I’ve listened to certain bands or songs so much that they become, in maybe a subconscious way, the palate or vocabulary I draw upon. I think of it as honing my musical instincts and becoming fluent in lots of songwriting styles in order to tap into my own means of expression.

PCR: In that same vein, when it came time to actually record were there any sounds you wanted to try and capture in the studio? For example, I’ve been listening to a lot of Simon & Garfunkel lately and am absolutely fascinated with the drums on songs like “The Boxer” and “The Only Living Boy in New York.” Someday I’d like to capture a sound like that on one of my own recordings.

PJ--The Only Living Boy in New York is one of my all time favorite songs and I love the production on the Simon and Garfunkel version, too. When it came time to make my record I knew there were some songs I wanted to be just acoustic guitar and vocal and others I wanted to add more instruments on. For instance, I wrote the first track, Throw A Line, on a keyboard with a piano/pad setting, which I thought created a vast ‘ocean’ kind of sound which fit the lyric. When it came time to make the record I chose to put the organ and drums in there because I thought it fit with the vibe of the rest of the ep. and was a bit more of a hopeful way to start the record. I like both versions, but there’s something about the piano/pad/vocal.

My thought process going into this project was to present the songs in a simple way - guitar/piano/singing - and then add other textures as time and inspiration allowed. I also gave myself freedom to change things up. I wrote Love Will Do on the acoustic guitar but the studio had a Rhodes piano which I couldn’t resist playing so it’s the main instrument on that track.

PCR: The song “Appeal to Heaven” seems very personal, like it’s your own personal plea to God, and yet the lyrics are universal enough that they could become anyone’s plea. Was this intentional on your part, that is, making it Psalm-like by being simultaneously intensely personal and still applicable to everyone?

PJ: That song was written shortly after we were finding out the extent of the earthquake in Haiti and I did write it as a kind of psalm. It is personal in that I connect very deeply with the sentiment of looking to God for answers, restoration, healing, and rest. However, when I wrote the song I was trying to put myself in the setting of a desperate and seemingly hopeless situation where my only option seemed to be getting on my knees and crying out to God. In the first verse, the person is crying to God, in the second the voice is turning to others in a plea for help - I’m thinking of that as a call to action for the church, and the third verse is offering true rest, peace, and hope at the source - God.

The phrase, Appeal to Heaven, comes from a flag used by the continental Navy in the American Revolution.

PCR: What are the stories behind the songs “The River (once again)” and “Be Still”?

I stumbled onto a version of the chorus to The River (Once Again) while I was singing/driving into work on a Monday morning and I sang it into my cell phone . As I was heading into my office I heard a coworker of mine comforting another coworker who was sobbing and devastated by an unexpected turn of events for her family. I went to the piano in the church sanctuary and wrote the first two verses and refined the chorus I was singing in the car to fit in with the new song. I wrote the lyrics in sympathy with my friend’s experience and wanted it to deal honestly with her pain and recognize that horrible things happen to good people. Instead of asking why this happened I wanted to write about what we do when things do happen. Going to the river, for me, is going to a place where we can rest in the midst of chaos and trust that there is hope coming with the morning light.

I wrote Be Still at my kitchen table after reading an email from the wife of a friend who had just died after dealing with ALS for some years. The email was an account of his last day and his death and I cried while I read it. At the same time I was starting to write this song my 5 month old daughter was sleeping in the next room. I wrote it as a letter to her, but also for my wife and I, or anyone who wants to ‘get it right‘ when it comes to telling the truth to our kids about hard things and faith, hope, and love. The idea for the last verse came from a magnet on our fridge.


 

PCR--A lot of your songs on Appeal to Heaven seem focused on taking people to another place (e.g., from a place of weariness to a place of rest, from safety to shelter, from death to resurrection, from this earth to the new heavens and the new earth, and from a place without God into God’s loving arms). Is this a real passion of yours with your music--to on one hand take people to another place through music but also to point the way to Another Place altogether using music?

PJ: I think that dichotomy is powerful and deep down something people long for. The great thing about writing this batch of songs is that after a while I started to recognize that they had this similar thread in them. I wrote them with the thought of ‘things are not as they should and not as they will be’ and also how do we live with that truth right here and now. I think I wrote these songs because I needed to. In this period of my experience, I needed to connect to the hope that comes from faith in a way that lodged deep in my own heart. By dealing with this concept through the songs I think it allows me as an artist to offer something to somebody that might be helpful and also point them toward the Gospel of Jesus.

PCR: As a music and worship leader one of my biggest interests is congregational singing or just getting people to sing in general. Do you ever write songs for your own congregation to sing and if so how have you approached that process, from a musical and lyrical perspective all the way through to teaching your song to the congregation?

I am starting to write songs for my congregation. I serve a Lutheran church in a ‘contemporary’ (if you will) setting and I think liturgically about themes or where a song might fit in worship. The one song I’ve written and used in worship is called Gathering (It’s You We Meet). I wrote it, as the title suggest, as a song to be sung before a Call to Worship, like an invitation to worship and prayer where we allow God to ‘tune our wandering hearts’ to his presence in the word and sacrament.

Musically it’s in 6/8, midtempo, and nestled into the key of Eb major. I tried to keep the melody simple and prayer like and I think the harmony is an important part of the picture here. I like the feeling of a well place minor ii7 chord.

PCR--What is it like being a musician in Central Illinois? What’s the “scene” like and how easy or hard is it to get your music out there and to find places to play?

I grew up in Central Illinois and really starting playing around for the first time as a drummer with country, rock, and jazz groups. There are many excellent players and bands in our region who are working almost every Friday and Saturday night.

Over the last year or so I’ve taken the time to get out to the local open mics and it’s been so good to meet people who love songs and writing. The kind of community that can build around a good open mic is such a vital thing for songwriters. It not only gives us a place to share it helps us realize that there is a scene here in Peoria that is important and worth supporting. Not because we’re becoming nationally renowned, but because it’s an outlet for human expression through art - sharing life in a way that is unique to music. That’s one of the reasons I love folk art and music - it’s made for the people who are making it and the local setting. It’s functional and it’s vital to our culture. I would love to see people supporting great local music in my hometown and celebrate new voices emerging locally.

I think Peoria does have a possibility of developing an even better music scene with places like 3030 coffee hosting live music and promoting it so well. I also see a place for the house concert series to take root and give good local writers an intimate venue and also attract touring groups.

PCR--You have a new page up on your website called the “Song Journal.” When can we expect you to put something up there and what kind of songs do you have waiting in the wings?

Yeah, the song journal is something I’ve wanted to do for a while. It’s just a place to post songs, like a blog, and invite people to listen. It’s very fulfilling to me for the songs to come full circle - from creator to listener. It also, for me, keeps things a little more pure in that I don’t feel like I have to be a salesmen for the art, just a person who is sharing something I made with the hope that a listener might connect with it.

Currently, I have three songs that I've written over the last month up on the page. I am allowing myself to be very open with the music I share so it will include music that I've written for my church as well as the folk/songwriter songs. There is one song that I'm excited to get out there called Sound of the Whistle, which is about soldiers in WWI getting ready to go over the top of the bunker to take out a machine gun nest.

+++ +++ +++

Patrick will be playing at The Blend, a coffee shop in Washington, IL, this Friday from 7-9 p.m.

You can find out more about Patrick and his music at his website, http://patrickjenkins.virb.com/ (make sure to check out the Song Journal for free downloads), and you can purchase his EP
Appeal to Heaven at itunes or CDbaby.


1.30.2012

Postlude: Thoughts on David Crowder Band's Pop Rock Requiem

(the guy on the right is Mozart, by the way)

I have been listening to David Crowder Band's album Give Us Rest for two weeks now. In my last post I shared some concerns about what that album might include (and not include). Here is what I think about it all so far:

+++Brief Review--I certainly would not say this is a masterpiece, but it is definitely very very good and worth everyone hearing. It has the possibility of being a great work, but we will have to let time and the Church's judgment decide that. All the music is solid and despite its length nothing feels forced-in or superfluous. In response to my previous concerns, I am happy to say there are a number of congregation-worthy songs (i.e., we could sing them in church). Since DCB had to stick to the themes and forms of a requiem the lyrics on the whole are less abstract and have deep roots in the Church's liturgy (a factor which also contributes to making them more singable in churches).

+++On that whole congregational singing thing...--In listening to this album I have come to see the work of the DCB differently. In the past wanted them to just be a worship band that merely contributes new entries to the hymn and worship song canon. Instead, I now see how they have slightly merged congregational songs with art song. While their work never reaches the heights of the vast library of what might be called "Classically Composed Sacred Music," it seems over the course of their career they have evolved into an art-rock project that creates larger works of art out of which the Church can then use a few pieces from during their times of worship. So, in the same way that Mozart gave us his Requiem and Bach gave us his cantatas and passions, DCB gave us some innovative art-rock to God's glory and the Church's pleasure. It is interesting to me that DCB's progression parallel's that of the Church's music, that is, from simple music (think monophonic Gregorian Chant, or DCB's first 2-3 albums), to larger more complex works that are not accessible to the common musician (think sprawling polyphonic orchestral works and DCB's concept albums).

+++Roman Catholic Anyone?--So, it has been made clear that this is a Requiem Mass, but as far as I know neither Crowder himself or anyone in his band is a Roman Catholic. Now this is fine--anyone can take any artistic form they like and make it into whatever they like. But surely there were some aspects of the mass that conflicted with Crowder's Baptist/Evangelical background. I know one song in particular, "Blessedness of Everlasting Light," is explicitly a prayer to God to forgive their sins of the dead. There are a lot of theological implications here, namely that basically all Evangelicals (and I use that term in the most generic sense possible) do not pray for their dead relatives and do not believe in the Purgatory they would supposedly be attempting to pray them out of. What I am wondering is if Crowder had any conflicts with the Catholic material he used as his base source and if he censored or watered down anything in his composing process? All this makes me want to become more familiar with the requiem liturgy so I can know how it fits with what Crowder did here. I do know I am not the only who has noticed this tension as both a Reformed and a Catholic blogger have written about it, the latter even going so far as to ask Crowder to join the one true church in Rome!

+++Easter Eggs!--DCB has been know for hiding Easter Eggs and inside jokes inside their albums. The album art for Give Us Rest features alternate versions of the covers from their previous albums, and many of the songs echo similar themes from previous albums (e.g., there's lots of "light" imagery a la Illuminate and lots of "death" imagery [of course] a la A Collision of which Give Us Rest is a companion album). I am sure there must be a lot of musical and lyrical parallels they cleverly put in for the discerning listener--I just hope I am smart enough to find them. I am sure some blogger has already gone through and found them all.

+++One Complaint--As someone who worships in what might be called a "liturgical" setting I was disappointed that Crowder did not leave us any actual Ordinary music for us church musicians to use. Besides the Kyrie Eleison, he does not use the exact liturgical texts, which is kind of a big deal for us liturgical types. For example, in the songs "After All (Holy)" and "Oh Great Love of God" Crowder buries sections of the Sanctus and the Agnus Dei in amongst his own lyrics. Now, both of these songs are pretty good and I would seriously think of using them during worship, but I would be all the more likely to use them had he stuck to the set texts. My disappointment is that he did not actually give us a new setting of the Sanctus or Agnus Dei, but rather new songs that reflect the themes of those liturgical texts. But hey, I realize this is the difference between someone who is writing solely for congregational work and someone who is trying to create their own separate work of art.

+++Genre Chameleon--I had a friend (the immortal Robbie Augsburger) who once said that people just did not put a bunch of different sounding songs on albums anymore, that albums tend to all sound the same nowadays. He referenced The Beatles’ ">Revolveras a great example of this, where every song had a unique sound, drawing from different genres and yet forming a cohesive whole over the course of the entire work. Well, his criticism certainly cannot be attached to DCB; over the course of their career they have explored many different sounds and genres and all of them find a prominent place on this final album: anthemic worship (obviously), quiet ballads, bluegrass/folk, pseudo-Trans-Siberianesque metal, (somewhat) classically composed choral and orchestral arrangements, pop punk, electronic/dance, and--a genre I think they are either an originator or perfecter of--what I would label “dance rock.” DCB takes us so many places over the duration of Give Us Rest, and yet nothing seems out of place--they manage remain true to their underlying sound and musical intuitions. The songs that tend to take up the core of their sound--electronically accented anthemic worship with a pop punk bent--start to sound the same after a while (and over the course of a 34 track album there are quite of few of them), and yet they still manage to be excellent songs in their own right. They have great melodic hooks and the lyrics are usually above standard.


+++Post DCB--In the Christianity Today interview Crowder said he's definitely going to keep making music, but I do not see how he can keep on making music anything close to this ambitious without his team behind him. Basically everyone in the band shared writing credits on this album, and it is clear to see that each member adds a lot to DCB's overall sound. Where does Crowder go from here? Release stripped down acoustic worship albums, discover his singer-songwriter side, become a bluegrass and folk superstar, or just quietly lead worship at a church somewhere? I am very curious to find out.

Please enjoy this video where Crowder and bandmate Jack Parker talk about the album a little:

1.10.2012

Mass Appeal?: Why I am Not Excited About the New (and last) David Crowder Band Album


Last week David Crowder Band released their last album Give Us Rest or (a requiem mass in c [the happiest of all keys]), which is in fact structured after a Catholic requiem mass. It is a double album that consists of 34 tracks. It is epic and is a grand final statement from a band that has done much to expand what we think worship music should sound like and how we should use words when singing to and about God.

And yet I am nearly all but unenthused about this release. In fact, I am pretty skeptical that it will be any good--at least on a very particular level. Let me explain why by asking and then attempting to answer a very simple question:

Why does(did) the David Crowder Band exist?

Was it simply to 1. make worship-ful music that generally glorified God in its musical artistry and through vertically focused lyrics, or was it to 2. make "Church Music," that is, music the church can sing? Because if it was the latter it is my belief that apart from a few scattered songs they all but failed at that aim. And of those songs will any of them even endure on to other generations? Of course from our vantage point it is impossible to tell, but I would say most likely not. One of the sad ironies of their 2009 album Church Music is there was barely anything on that album the church could actually use--and that is not a good prognosis for a work with a title such as that and which consists of 17 tracks and way over an hour of music. While obviously performed and recorded with great musical excellence, it for the most part is a bloated and bland album, with music and lyrics that lack any punch. (The only song on there I would actually have a congregation sing during worship is "Shadows," as I was never really a fan of the popular John Mark McMillan tune "How He Loves.") (You might ask "How can he think songs like "God Almighty, None Compares" or "Oh, Happiness" are bland?" Well, it is really hard to defend subjective musical experiences, so I can really only answer by saying "I don't know! I just didn't find them interesting, despite the noted ambitious attempt.")

Please hear on me this. I am not saying David Crowder Band's music is not "worship music," I am simply saying that most of it will never find its way into churches, which to me is always the most important criteria for labeling anything as "worship music." To be sure, as artists they have done much in attempt to redefine the worship genre. They talk about God differently than in "typical" worship songs (of which there is no such thing) and they have a lot of songs that make you want to dance (i.e., they fully encourage us to embrace an incarnational [see: holistic] understanding of corporate worship). However my contention is that in their attempt to do something new, they have not actually left us with much that is usable.

I am pretty conventional to when it comes to what constitutes church music: 1. the music has to be singable but enduring and 2. the lyrics need to be approachable but at the same time theologically and literarily excellent. It is not very often that Crowder's music fits into this sweet spot. My favorite songs of his are usually too complex musically or too abstract lyrically to be sung in church, and the songs that actually are simple and approachable lack substance both musically and lyrically. In other words, it is great music and usually a lot of fun, but it just will not find a place in the worship repertoire of most churches.

Again, please hear me on this. I love this band and have been a long time fan. I think I am simply lamenting the fact that someone so talented has left the church with so little to actually sing. The same exact thing could be said for another "worship" band, Deliriou5?, who, for the latter 75% of their career gave the Church next to nothing to sing on a Sunday morning (but that's for another blog post).

As to the first answer of the question I posed above (that of making God-glorifying art) I would say they entirely succeeded. I think a decent chunk of every one of their albums has given us some great musical moments. Apart from the peculiarly obligatory "youth-group-song" and "Christian-radio-friendly-adult-contemporary-song" present on basically every album (record company pressure? enduring royalty checks? or simply an appeal for more mass appeal?) they are among the best "Christian" rock bands of the new millenium. This is why even though I am not holding my breath for a lot of congregation-ready songs on Give Us Rest, I am expecting to be blown away musically.

By choice I have not listened to a single second of the album yet and am expectantly awaiting its arrival in the mail (yes, I purchased a real physical copy of the album). So heres to being proved wrong! Hope still prevails...

You can find an interview Christianity Today did with David Crowder here. He discusses the album, the end of the band, and hints at what he will do in the future.

Last night I surveyed through every single one of DCB's songs in an attempt to decide which ones I found to be "congregational." So here's my list (because you REALLY wanted to know):


You Alone
Our Love is Loud
Wonderful King
Thank You For Hearing Me*
O Praise Him (All This For a King)
All Creatures of Our God and King*
Only You*
Come and Listen
Here is Our King
The Glory of it All
O For a Thousand Tongues to Sing*
Remedy
Shadows

What would make your list? Remember, I'm looking for songs a congregation would sing.


* = they did not actually write this song

12.20.2011

Lists 2011--Week #3--Absolute Favorites and Book Lists



Welcome to our last week of lists over at PostConsumer Reports. This week we have my book lists for the year as well my absolute favorites, that is, the most favoritest things I consumed this year out of everything that was consumed. I also include a list of my biggest disappointments in consumption.








Absolute Favorites—2011—An assorted list—In Order

1. Fernando Ortega’s Come Down O Love Divine—For a few months we were listening to this album everyday of the week in my household. His music really has become deeply ingrained in our lives. I also really enjoyed teaching myself his setting of “Trisagion” on piano and then teaching it to people at a women’s retreat as well as to my church. His music is truly a blessing.
2. Louis C.K.—Both his standup and his FX tv show “Louie.” Is there a funnier more sincerely revealing comic out there? Is there a more creative comedic television show currently on air? No, there certainly is not. (Please note his comedy is quite often more than a little crass. You were warned.)
3. Rev.—This British sitcom about a Church of England vicar/priest/pastor/whatever is a really refreshing and heartfelt take on Christianity, and Tom Hollander is just brilliant in the lead role.
4. Friday Night Lights—It was the last season of this stellar show. It made me so sad to have to say goodbye to Coach Taylor and Tim Riggins.
5. “The Only Living Boy in New York” (Simon & Garfunkel), “Cruel” (St. Vincent), “Bizness” (tune yards), and “Trisagion” (Fernandon Ortega)—My biggest earworms of the year.
6. WTF Podcast—I have tremendously enjoyed these interviews of various comics. As a comic himself Marc Maron is a great interviewer and it is fascinating getting inside the heads of these people who make us laugh. Louis C.K’s and Judd Apatow’s interviews were probably my favorites. (Again, a warning: this is not exactly the cleanest of podcasts.)
7. The Drew Marshall Show—A Canadian Christian radio talk show. Drew has basically the best guests you could imagine for a show covering Christian topics, and his naturally curmudgeonly nature forces his to ask some great questions.
8. “My Soul Magnifies the Lord” by Chris Tomlin off of his Christmas album Glory in the Highest—This is just a great Advent/Christmas worship song. I really hope it starts to catch on in the churches.
9. The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoyevsky—I cannot believe I actually made it through this book (and I still hardly know what it all means). I will have to read it again in ten years.
10. Community--The third season of this show has just been spectacular. It is really hitting its stride. Heres to hoping it will last a few more seasons.

Biggest Disappointments of the Year—An Assorted List—In Order

1. Life’s Too Short—British sitcom---Oh Ricky Gervais, art thou getting too full of thyself? Warwick Davis is actually really good in the lead role, but the rest of the show is just a poorly done Extras retread.
2. 10,000 Reasons by Matt Redman—Worship album—Meh…
3. News that Sufjan Stevens was not going to release a live version of his Age of Adz tour on DVD, as well as the fact that he still has not officially released any new Christmas music for like five years now and we all just KNOW he is recording new songs every year.
4. The Office—U.S. version of the tv sitcom—What an awful show it has become (even before Steve Carell left).
5. The new Winnie the Pooh movie—This was certainly not a bad movie; it just failed to capture the magical innocence of the original film(s), which I had really hoped it would do.


Books
Since most of my reading is done for the teaching I do at school, my booklist for this year is more of a wishlist.

The First Five Nonfiction Books I Would Read Right Now If I Had All The Time In The World

1.The New Testament and the People of God--N.T. Wright
2.God’s Empowering Presence--Gordon Fee
3.A History of the Church in England--JRH Moorman
4.The Apostolic Fathers--The Apostolic Fathers
5.Commentary on the American Prayer Book--Marion J. Hatchett


The First Five Fiction Books I Would Read Right Now If I Had All The Time In The World

1.Infinite Jest--David Foster Wallace
2.Blood Meridian--Cormac McCarthy
3.Tristram Shandy--Laurence Stern
4.Shame--Salman Rushdie
5.Moby Dick--Herman Mellville

12.15.2011

Lists 2011!--Week #2--Movies


I love movies--don't you? Here are my movie lists for 2011, some having to do with movies coming out this year or at least movies I saw this year for the first time and the rest consisting of topics of personal interest, because, well, lists are just fun to make!


Top 5 Movies I Saw This Year That Really Surprised Me (in a good way)

  1. In The Loop (Funny!)
  2. The Road (Depressing, disturbing, and yet hopeful)
  3. Catfish (Is this for real?)
  4. Lars and the Real Girl (Oh so very touching and not what I expected. And did I mention Ryan Gosling? New man-crush!)
  5. Sunshine (Zombie sci-fi! And the sun!--it's so big and bright)

Top 5 Movies I Want to See the Most That Have Come Out/Are Coming Out This Year (that I have not yet seen)

  1. Hugo
  2. The Adventures of Tintin
  3. Warhorse
  4. The Descendants
  5. Drive
Filmakers Whose Movies I Love But Who Also Thoroughly Depress and/or Confuse Me
  1. Ingmar Bergman (SO good but Soooo depressing)
  2. Stanley Kubrick (Can you feel the angst?)
  3. Wes Anderson (only half the time)
  4. P.T. Anderson (only 3/4 of the time)
  5. Charlie Kaufman/Spike Jonze (Have you SEEN Synecdoche, New York?)
  6. Akira Kurosawa (Did you know he tried to commit suicide once?)



Top 5 Coen Brothers’ Films (In order) (Because they are my most favoritist of all)

  1. The Big Lebowski
  2. No Country For Old Men
  3. Barton Fink
  4. A Serious Man
  5. Fargo



Top 5 Least Favorite Coen Brothers’ Films (#1 is my least favorite)

  1. The Ladykillers (oh what an awful film)
  2. Intolerable Cruelty (it had its moments, but still...)
  3. The Hudsucker Proxy (many, many great moments, but many blah moments as well)
  4. Miller’s Crossing (definitely not a BAD film, and again, definitely some great moments, but on the whole it fell flat for me)
  5. True Grit (If I’m to be honest with myself, I didn’t really enjoy this movie that much, at least not compared to their other films. It left me mostly cold.)




12.09.2011

Making Some Lists...2011 Edition


It is nearing the end of the year and is therefore time for everyone to start putting out their year end lists for anything they can think of. As a longtime lover of lists I have decided to join in the fun. I, however, certainly do not have the time nor the resources to have watched all the year's new movies or listened to all the year's new music, so there's no way I could ever come up with a "Best of" list for 2011 in any category. My lists, therefore, will be purely idiosyncratic. Over the next three weeks I will do some music lists, some movie lists, and some book lists.

Up this week: Music

List #1--Artists Whose Music I Love But Too Much Time Has Past For Me To Actually Start Buying Their Records

  1. Sigur Ros
  2. Iron and Wine
  3. Larry Norman
  4. ELO (Electric Light Orchestra)
  5. Queen
  6. Bill Withers
  7. Lilly Allen
  8. LCD Soundsystem
  9. Bjork
  10. Calexico
  11. Cat Stevens
  12. Gnarls Barkley
  13. John Lennon and Paul McCartney (solo records)
  14. Muse

List #2--Artists Whose Music I Know Very Little About But Whom I Want to Know More About and If I Had Any Expendable Time or Income I May One Day Start Purchasing Their Records (donations are not being accepted at this time)

  1. Tune Yards
  2. Wye Oak
  3. Avett Brothers
  4. Imelda May
  5. Janelle Monae
  6. Joanna Newsom
  7. Duke Ellington
  8. John Prine
  9. John Tavener
  10. Juana Molina
  11. Knaan
  12. Raphael Saadiq
  13. Kraftwerk
  14. Mastodon
  15. Nellie Mckay
  16. Neu!
  17. Devotchka
  18. Godspeed You Black Emperor
  19. A Tribe Called Quest
  20. The Legendary Shack Shakers
  21. Toumani Diabate
  22. Mariachi El Bronx
  23. Jordi Savall
  24. Hildegaard Von Bingen
  25. Afro-pop music (to use a very general, non-helpful term)

List #3--Artists That Others Love and Adore Whom I Absolutely Cannot Stand (Believe me I’ve tried)

  1. Pink Floyd (top of the list)
  2. David Bowie (I hate Bowie only 90% of the time, but that 90% is very intense)
  3. The Rolling Stones
  4. The Flaming Lips
  5. They Might Be Giants
  6. The Doors
  7. Tom Waits
  8. James Taylor
  9. Elvis Costello


List #4--Artists Whose Music You May Not Listen Too Whose Music I Think You Should Start Buying (If you already know these artists then don’t bother with this list)

  1. Andrew Osenga
  2. Keith Green, Rich Mullins, and Fernando Ortega (of course!)
  3. Over the Rhine
  4. Explosions in the Sky
  5. Brooke Waggoner
  6. Burlap To Cashmere
  7. Vince Guaraldi
  8. Charlie Peacock
  9. Jeremy Casella
  10. John Reuben
  11. Josh Garrells
  12. Waterdeep
  13. Loney, Dear
  14. Elbow
  15. MuteMath
  16. The Normals
  17. Phil Keaggy
  18. Randy Newman (He’s written a lot of stuff OTHER than the Toy Story theme song)
  19. Steve Reich
  20. Taize
  21. Steven Delopoulos
  22. Steve Taylor
  23. J.S. Bach (I’m serious about this one. Go and listen to Bach. Now. Actually, we all should just go listen to Bach right now.)